Ask a group of new pilots who flies the shortest line round a track, the novice or the champion, and most will guess the novice. It's the other way round. This guide is about the racing line: what it is, why it is almost always the shortest and the smoothest line, and how good pilots find it. A great lap comes in four steps: slow down, make it short, make it smooth, then add speed.
What is a racing line?
The racing line is the path round the track that loses the least time. Look at three pilots through the same gates:
- Point and shoot. Lines up on every gate to take it straight on, at 90°. Straight through, overshoot, turn, line up again. Two sharp turns per gate, stop and go. The longest line.
- Intermediate. The same idea, but rounder. Still turns after the gate, so the line is a little longer than it needs to be.
- Flow. Turns early, before the gate, and takes it at an angle. One turn per gate, steady full throttle. The shortest line, and the fastest.
Cars and drones
Car racers have a racing line too. They start a corner wide, kiss the apex on the inside and go wide again. They fight the grip of the road: a car wants to go straight, and anything that changes that kills speed. A drone is not that different:
- Both want to go straight. Every change of direction costs speed. On a drone you can hear it: the props squeal.
- No edges. A car has to stay on the road. We have only the gates and the ground, so the short line is open.
- Up and down count. Our line is 3D. Climbing costs speed and diving gives it back, like a roller coaster.
Four steps to a great lap
A great lap time grows in four steps:
- Slow down. Fly slow enough to fly the track right, every lap. You will already be faster.
- Make it short. Turn early and cut close to the gates. No wide swings.
- Make it smooth. Steady throttle, fewer and rounder inputs.
- Add speed, but keep the line. Only now go faster.
Take an example lap of 100 seconds. Slowing down brings it to about 80, a short line to about 50, a smooth line to about 20, and adding speed to about 10. Every step shows on the leaderboard. This isn't made up. At a Viimsi race, the top qualifier flew three laps in 31.061 seconds. A pilot flying his first race needed 1:59.852 for the same three laps: almost four times as long.
31.061 s
1:59.852
Step 1: slow down
If you're too fast for your skill, slow down first. A fast lap only counts if you can fly it every lap. Three clean laps beat one fast lap and two crashes, and going back for a missed gate costs far more than flying it a little slower. Racers say consistency is king. If a section keeps going wrong, slow it down and fly it smoothly. Lap times often drop.
Step 2: make it short
Wide lines add distance, and distance is time. Over a full course, the fastest pilots can fly less than half the distance a novice does. The novice lines up on every gate, overshoots, swings wide, and now and then misses a gate and goes back for it. The fast pilot turns early and cuts close to every gate.
Face the exit before the gate
The trick that makes a line short is the pre-turn. Start the turn before the gate, so that you already face the exit as you go through. Let your speed carry you through the gate, then open the throttle. If you turn after the gate, you have to brake, turn and line up again, and you come out of the gate slowly.
Look one or more gates ahead
Your line starts with your eyes. Researchers at the University of Zurich tracked the eyes of 21 experienced pilots in a simulator:
- 1.5 seconds. Pilots first looked at a gate about 1.5 seconds before they reached it, about 16 m ahead.
- 0.2 seconds. The eyes moved first, and the hands followed about 0.2 seconds later.
- Late is a crash. Before a crash, pilots looked at the gate later than on clean laps.
Look at the next gate as soon as you're through the current one, and look at the inside of the turn.
Three ways to see a track
Most racing pilots go through three stages in how they see a track. Not everyone, but roughly:
- Magnetic gates. Every gate pulls you in, and so does anything else in the field: a branch, a tree, a single flag. You fly the track as separate gates and obstacles: pass one, then look for the next. Motorcyclists call this target fixation: you go where you look.
- Gates become flags. You only worry about the post that matters, not the whole gate. That frees up your head for the line.
- Flow. You only see your line. The gates may as well not be there. Psychologists call it flow: being completely absorbed in what you're doing, when your skill matches the challenge.
It's a step up in skill, but it's also a way of getting rid of what you don't need.
Step 3: make it smooth
Short and smooth are two different things. A line can be short and full of sharp corners, or smooth and far too wide. Once your line is short, make it smooth. Smooth means you slow down and speed up less often:
- Less braking. Every chop of the throttle loses speed, and speed takes time to get back. Keep the throttle high and steady.
- Less propwash. Chopping the throttle drops the drone into its own dirty air, and it shakes. A good tune hides some of that, but steady throttle avoids it.
- Less turning round. Fewer, rounder inputs mean less time spent pointing the drone a new way. One input, held, does the whole turn. That is what flow feels like.
Three pilots, one ladder
A ladder is three gates stacked on top of each other, flown downwards in a spiral round one post. It shows the difference well:
- Too fast: point and shoot. Takes it as three separate gates: wham through, overshoot, sharp turn, wham back past, sharp turn, next gate. Nose down on the straights, pitch back to stop in the corners, nose down again. The props squeal in every corner.
- Intermediate: flat and careful. Has stopped mashing the sticks. Flies at a low angle, so the drone has to yaw round the post. The throttle goes up and down a little.
- Great pilot: one flowing move. Flies at a high angle, so the drone banks hard and almost rolls round the post. Throttle high and steady. A good pilot is about a second faster than a novice; a great one flies the whole ladder as one move.
On a drone you can't hear the motors, only the props. Sharp changes of direction make them squeal, because one set of motors suddenly works very hard. An even prop sound is a smooth line.
Even champions have time to find
Step 4 is adding speed, and there is always more to find. Researchers in Zurich let a computer plan the perfect line round a track and raced it against two expert pilots. The computer's line was about 10 % faster than the pilots' best laps, and about ten times steadier from lap to lap. The reason: pilots plan only a gate or two ahead and don't hold full power all the way round. Even the best pilots have time to find, and so do you.
Slow down, make it short, make it smooth, then add speed.
How to train so you can fly the line is in the next talks: train your sticks, train your body and train your mind.
Read
- GetFPV: How to find the perfect drone racing line
lines through common elements, point and shoot vs fluid. - Five33: Improve your lap time with Evan "Headsup" Turner
exits, angles and consistency. - MultiGP: Drone racing training, part 2
race pilots on consistency and lines. - Pfeiffer & Scaramuzza: Human-piloted drone racing (arXiv)
where pilots look. - Pfeiffer et al.: Expertise affects drone racing performance (arXiv)
professionals against beginners, lines and speed. - Foehn et al.: Time-optimal planning for quadrotor waypoint flight
the computer line against expert pilots. - Oscar Liang: Propwash
what propwash is and when it happens. - Wikipedia: Racing line
the car version.
For trainers: the 10-minute plan
| Time | Slide | Talking points |
|---|---|---|
| 0:00 | Title | Ask: "Who flies the shortest line round a track: the novice or the champion?" Let them guess. "Today you'll see why it's the champion." |
| 0:30 | Fig. 1 | Three pilots through the same three gates. Point and shoot lines up on every gate, goes straight through, overshoots and turns twice per gate: longest, stop and go. The intermediate does the same, but rounder. The flow pilot turns early and takes the gate at an angle: shortest, steady full throttle. Colour and width show speed: blue is slow, orange is full throttle. Short first, then smooth. |
| 1:10 | Fig. 2 | Car racers have a racing line too: start wide, kiss the apex on the inside, go wide again. They fight the grip of the road: a car wants to go straight, and every change of direction kills speed. A drone is not that different: it also wants to go straight, and every change of direction costs speed and makes the props squeal. But we have no road edges, only gates and the ground, so the short line is open. And our line is 3D: height costs and gives speed. |
| 2:00 | Fig. 3 | Four steps to a great lap. Slow down, make it short, make it smooth, then add speed, but keep the line. An example lap goes from 100 seconds to 80, 50, 20 and finally 10, and you climb the leaderboard. Real numbers from a Viimsi race: three laps in 31.061 s for the top qualifier, 1:59.852 for a pilot in his first race. The rest of the talk takes the steps one by one. |
| 2:50 | Fig. 4 | Step 1: slow down. Too fast for your skill? A fast lap only counts if you can fly it every lap. Three clean laps beat one fast lap and two crashes. Missed gates cost far more than flying a little slower. Is a section going wrong? Slow it down and fly it smooth: lap times often drop. |
| 3:40 | Fig. 5 | Step 2: make it short. Wide lines add distance. Over a full course, the fastest pilots can fly less than half the distance a novice does. The novice lines up on every gate, overshoots, swings wide and goes back for a missed gate. |
| 4:20 | Fig. 6 | Face the exit before the gate. Pilots call it the pre-turn: start the turn before the gate, so you already face the exit as you go through. Let your speed carry you through, then full throttle. Turning after the gate means brake, turn, line up again. |
| 5:00 | Fig. 7 | The line starts with your eyes. In a study with 21 experienced pilots, they looked at a gate about 1.5 s, or 16 m, before reaching it, and their hands followed about 0.2 s after the eyes. Before a crash they looked later. Look at the next gate, at the inside of the turn. |
| 5:40 | Fig. 8 | Three ways to see a track. First, magnetic gates: every gate, and every branch in the field, pulls you in, and you fly one gate at a time. Then gates become flags: you only worry about the post that matters, not the whole gate. Finally flow: you only see your line. It's a step up in skill, and it's also getting rid of what you don't need. |
| 6:30 | Fig. 9 | Step 3: make it smooth. Smooth means you slow down and speed up less often. Throttle high and steady, fewer, rounder inputs. Less braking, less propwash, less time spent turning the drone round. That is flow. |
| 7:20 | Fig. 10 | Three pilots, one ladder. Point and shoot takes it as three gates: nose down on the straights, pitch back to stop in the corners, and the props squeal in every corner. The intermediate is flat and careful, yaws round, throttle not steady yet. The great pilot banks hard and rolls round the post on steady throttle, as one move, seconds faster. Listen to the props: an even sound is a smooth line. |
| 8:20 | Fig. 11 | Step 4: add speed, keep the line. Even champions have time to find. Researchers in Zurich let a computer plan the perfect line: it was about 10 % faster than two expert pilots and ten times steadier. Pilots plan a gate or two ahead and don't hold full power all the way. So there's always time to find. |
| 9:10 | Remember | "Slow down, make it short, make it smooth, then add speed." Next talks: train your sticks, your body and your mind. |
Demo: Put two cones on the floor, a few metres apart. Two volunteers run round both and back as fast as they can. One runs straight at each cone, stops and turns round it. The other starts curving early and keeps running. Time both, and count the steps. The early turner runs a shorter path and doesn't stop. Then ask: "Where were you looking?"